This is higher than the county median home value of $ 152,625. Browse photos, watch virtual tours and create a "Favorites" account to save, organize and share your favorite properties. The average price of homes sold in Middlebury, IN is $ 227,500. Right now, there are 41 homes listed for sale in Middlebury, including 1 condos and 0 foreclosures. Get in touch with a Middlebury real estate agent who can help you find the home of your dreams in Middlebury. Coldwell Banker estimates the median home price in Middlebury is $263,000. Right now, there are 44 homes listed for sale in Middlebury, including 1 condos and 0 foreclosures. The national median home value is $ 231,815. There are 47 real estate listings found in Middlebury, IN.View our Middlebury real estate area information to learn about the weather, local school districts, demographic data, and general information about Middlebury, IN. Included below, and updated daily from the MLS, are homes for sale in Middlebury, IN, a city located in Elkhart County.. For more information on any of these Middlebury real estate listings, just click the "Request More Information" button when viewing the details of a property. Homes for Sale Middlebury IN. Approximately 72% of Middlebury homes are owned, compared to 23% rented, while 5% are vacant. Middlebury Indiana Homes for Sale. Browse through our real estate listings in Middlebury, IN. The median home value in Middlebury, IN is $ 227,500. You can research home values, browse Middlebury's hottest homes, and see what Coldwell Banker… Also review up-to-date market research and local market conditions as well as neighborhood and school information. Real Estate Market Trends in Middlebury, IN Century 21 estimates the median home price in Middlebury is $251,450.